5 Myths About Men's Silver Chain Necklaces That Cost Me $200

I wasted a lot of money on cheap jewelry. I assumed buying a men's silver chain necklace would be straightforward, but I was mistaken. I ended up with chains that faded within two weeks and necklaces that left green marks on my skin. It cost me over $200 to learn these lessons the hard way.

Let me share the truth that sellers don't want you to know. If you're in the market for jewelry, you need to read this first. This guide will help you:

Myth #1: Price Equals Value (A Cheap Chain Must Be a Good Deal)

This is the biggest misconception. Many people look for the lowest price, spotting a heavy-looking chain online for $19.99 and thinking they've found a bargain. What they don't realize is that such a low price often means the materials are subpar.

In higher-end jewelry sales, buyers quickly learn that a high price tag can sometimes hide low-quality components. One disappointed customer realized this too late, stating:

The same issue applies to cheap chains. You might think you're buying solid silver, but you're actually getting a low-quality core metal with an extremely thin layer of plating. The "worthless band" mentioned in the review is similar to the flimsy metal inside a cheap chain.

The Truth: True value comes from the material, not the initial price. A quality chain should be made from sterling silver (.925) or high-grade stainless steel like 316L. Anything less is likely to rust or discolor your skin quickly.

Myth #2: Plating Quality Doesn't Matter (Silver is Silver)

When jewelry is plated, a thin layer of gold or silver is applied over a cheaper metal to enhance its appearance. However, not all plating is created equal.

If a chain is cheap—say under $40—it likely uses "flash plating" or "dip plating," where the chain is briefly dipped into a metallic solution. This results in an extremely thin layer that sweat, water, and cologne can wear away in just days.

High-quality plating is measured in microns. Even one micron is significantly better than flash plating. If the seller doesn't specify the micron count or mention a durable method like PVD (Physical Vapor Deposition), assume it's low quality.

The Truth: Plating thickness determines whether a necklace lasts a year or a week. If the seller avoids providing material details, they're likely hiding poor quality.

Myth #3: You Can Trust the Chain Size in the Ad Photo

Online jewelry sellers often use tricks to make chains appear larger. They take extreme close-up shots, place the chain on a slender model, or use small reference objects. This can make a 3mm or 4mm chain look like a substantial 8mm piece.

When your order arrives, the chain may look tiny and feel flimsy—a common complaint among buyers.